Is there any difference between "sh -c 'some comand'" and directly run some command

user_4082286 0
Viewed 50

let's say echo command, we can run that command by two ways:

# by 1
echo 'hello'
# or by 2
sh -c "echo 'hello'"

Is there any difference between the two ways? By the way, I can see the way 2 is very popular in yaml config files.

- name: init-mydb
  image: busybox:1.28
  command: ['sh', '-c', "sleep 2; done"]
sh shell
2 Answers

The first way calls an inherited command interpreter, eg from a terminal running /bin/bash ; the second way exec sh (aka Bourne Shell) as the interpreter and instruct him ( -c ) to do something.

sh, ksh, csh, bash are all shell interpreters. They provide some features that are not always compatible between them. So, if you don't know the environment where your program will run, the best is to specify the interpreter you want, which is less error prone.

user_124466690

This is a single command:

foo 1 2 3

So is this

sh -c 'foo 1 2 3'

This is not a single command (but rather a pair of commands separated by a ;)

foo; bar

but this is

sh -c "foo; bar"

This does not specify a command using the name of a executable file

for x in 1 2 3; do echo "$x"; done

but this does

sh -c 'for x in 1 2 3; do echo "$x"; done'

sh -c is basically way to specify an arbitrary shell script as a single argument to a command that can be executed from a file.

user_11268410
Related