Are there any JDK 11+ system modules which are not root modules?

Question

In JDKs 9 and 10, there used to be a few modules such as java.xml.bind, containing Java EE classes. They were marked as deprecated and to be removed with the advent of JDK 9 and finally removed in 11 (see JEP 320). In a product I am contributing to, there used to be tests for the javac compiler option --add-modules, adding those modules as root modules. Those tests have been deactivated for JDK 11+. Instead of removing them, I would like to reactivate them, if there are any other JDK modules which are also non-root by default. The tests could then just use those modules instead.

I know I can just test --add-modules with my own modules, but then I have to specify them on the module path. The test case that an extra module path is not necessary for JDK modules added via --add-modules is also interesting, if any JDK 11+ modules still exist to be tested against. I am not talking about non-exported packages, but really about non-root JDK modules.

So, according to the information in this answer, I am actually looking for non-java.* modules among the system modules which do not export at least one package without qualification. In that case, those modules should not be root, and they would be eligible for my test case.

Update: What I am looking for is an equivalent for this in JDK 9:

import javax.xml.bind.JAXBContext;

public class UsesJAXB {
  JAXBContext context;
}

xx> "C:\Program Files\Java\jdk-9.0.4\bin"\javac UsesJAXB.java
UsesJAXB.java:1: error: package javax.xml.bind is not visible
import javax.xml.bind.JAXBContext;
                ^
  (package javax.xml.bind is declared in module java.xml.bind, which is not in the module graph)
1 error

xx> "C:\Program Files\Java\jdk-9.0.4\bin"\javac --add-modules java.xml.bind UsesJAXB.java

See? With --add-modules it builds, without it does not.

I am looking for modules (if any) in JDK 11-18, which would yield the same result when importing their classes in a simple program, i.e. require them to be explicitly added via --add-modules for compilation (not talking about runtime).

user_8182287 · Answer

You can list all modules of the jdk with:

java --list-modules

Then you can print the module descriptors with:

java --describe-module a.module.name

After filterting these outputs in a little script, here are the modules of my JDK 17 than could qualify:

jdk.charsets
jdk.crypto.cryptoki
jdk.crypto.ec
jdk.editpad
jdk.internal.vm.compiler
jdk.internal.vm.compiler.management
jdk.jcmd
jdk.jdwp.agent
jdk.jlink
jdk.jpackage
jdk.localedata
jdk.zipfs

jdk.charsets, for instance, is a module providing a service.

Update after question update

So you are looking for a module that exports a package but is not in the default module graph when compiling a class in the unnamed module. According to the JEP, only java.* modules can qualify.

When I'm looking for modules required, either directly or indirectly, by java.se (which is a root module when it exists), I see all java.* modules of the JDK, but java.smartcardio. And due to some unknown magic, java.smartcardio is also in the default graph : I tried to compile a class importing one of its class and it works without --add-modules.

So I think you are down to using a non-java module exporting no package (like jdk.charsets), importing one of its class (like sun.nio.cs.ext.ExtendedCharsets) and either:

add --add-exports in addition to --add-modules when compiling your test class so that javac succeeds.
or parse the error message of javac and distinguish between "not in the module graph" and "not exported".

Are there any JDK 11+ system modules which are not root modules?

1 Answers