Sizeof string vs sizeof string pointer

user_12283168 0
Viewed 417

In the following code:

char *title = "VP";
printf("Sizeof title: %zd | Sizeof *title: %zd | Strlen: %zd\n", sizeof title, sizeof *title, strlen(title));

Sizeof title: 8 | Sizeof *title: 1 | Strlen: 2

It seems like the sizeof title operates on the pointer to the string (8 bytes for me), and the strlen(title) predictably gives me 2.

Why does the sizeof *title produce 1 when dereferencing the pointer rather than 3 (the byte-length of the string)? For example, why does it do that instead of what it would produce for:

printf("%zd\n", sizeof("VP"));
// 3
c
2 Answers

The size of a pointer is always the size of the pointer itself, not what it points to. That's because sizeof is mostly a compile-time operator (the result is evaluated by the compiler) and the compiler can't know what a pointer might point to at run-time.

As for sizeof *title it's the same as sizeof title[0] which is a single char. And the size of a char is 1 (it's specified to always be 1 by the way, no matter the actual bit-width).

Lastly about sizeof "VP". In C all literal strings are really arrays of characters, including the terminating null character. So the literal string "VP" is an array of three characters, hence its size is 3.

To make the answer a little bit more complete, I say that the sizeof operator is mostly compile-time. That of course can't be true for variable-length arrays, where the compiler must insert code to store the actual size of the array in a way that it can be fetched at run-time. If the array decays to a pointer, then all you have is the pointer and again sizeof returns the size of the pointer itself.

And a note about string literal arrays. While they are technically non-constant arrays, they still can't be modified. Attempting to modify a string literal leads to undefined behavior. Literal strings are thus, in effect, read-only.

user_4405580

The type of title is char *, so the type of *title is char, not char [3]. Thus , sizeof *title is equivalent to sizeof (char), which is 1.

title isn’t the string, it just points to the first element of the string.

user_1345540
Related