Dependencies in Monorepo

user_13054228 0
Viewed 1168

In a monorepo, if you have a dependency in one package can you use that dependency in another package without adding it to that package? For more clarity, check the below layout.

Project
   |-packages
       |- packageA
            |- package.json (Here let say I have lodash dependency)
            |- index.js
       |- packageB
            |-package.json (I haven't added lodash here.)
            |- index.js

So, can I import lodash in packageB's index.js or do I have to add it there?

monorepo javascript
2 Answers

If packageB use lodash, you should list lodash in the package.json file of packageB. If you don't, bad things could happen. For example, consider the following situations:

  1. lodash is removed from packageA. In your case, you mentioned that packageA lists lodash as a dependency. However, if down the road you refactored packageA where it no longer needs lodash, you might remove it thinking that it is unused. If packageB was relying on packageA installing lodash, then packageB would break due to the missing dependency.
  2. packageB is installed without packageA. Without knowing what your packages contain it's hard to know for sure, but it is possible that now or down the road you (or someone else) could install packageB without installing packageA. You would then wind up with the same situation where lodash is not installed and packageB would break.
  3. packageA updates to a new major version of lodash. If packageB is no longer compatible with the new major version of lodash, it could break. This would not be a problem if packageB specified it's own dependency on lodash as you could update them together or separately depending on what is best.

Other situations could happen, these are just a few examples.

Note, you could specify lodash as a peer dependency in both packageA and packageB letting the consuming application install lodash so you don't have to install it in both packages, but that doesn't really simplify things either in your monorepo or in your consuming applications.

user_56416740

As being different packages, you have to you the dependency in both. You can use Lerna for monorepo to match dependencies and assign as root dependecy.

lerna link convert
user_39386760
Related