Do I need CSRF-protection without users or login?

user_13672435 0
Viewed 946

I am building a Django application where people can register for events. Everyone can register, there's no user account or login, i.e. no authentication. Verification is done through an an email with a link that has to be clicked in order to activate the registration. I'm unsure whether I need to enable CSRF-protection for these forms. It boils down to the following question: Is CSRF-protection necessary for every POST-request (which doesn't leave the domain) or only for POST-requests by logged-in users?

What could be done with a CSRF-attack? I know you can use it to circumvent the same origin policy and post whatever you want in the name of the user, but can you also use it to alter a real post by the user or steal their data? If a malicious site could learn the data the user posted or silently alter their request that would be a reason for me to use it. If it just means that another website can create additional registrations then no, because so can everyone else. (I know that it doesn't cost much to just use it everywhere and I might in fact do that, but I'm trying to understand the principle better)

csrf django
2 Answers

Contrary to the other answer, CSRF fundamentally is not about sending cookies. CSRF is about another website being able to have a user visiting it send a request to your application. If there is a session, it needs to be via something like cookies for this to be successful, because cookies for example will be sent automatically. But there are other forms of authentication that will be sent automatically, for example client certificates.

Also if there is no authentication, even easier, requests can be made. And that sounds like a problem in your case too.

What another website can do is if a user visit them, they can have that user perform actions in your application. For example they can have them register for an event, without them even noticing it. Or the malicious website can deregister people from events if that's possible. They can do whatever in the name of the victim user that is possible on your website, without the victim knowing about it, just by having them visiting the malicious website.

So to put it another way, the probelm is not that another website can perform actions in your application - they could do it with CSRF enabled too if there is no authentication. But without CSRF protection, they can have your users perform actions inadvertently in your application, just by having them visit the malicious website.

Only you can tell, whether this is a problem in your case. Without more info, I think you should have CSRF protection enabled.

user_65700420

CSRF attacks rely on the fact that the browser will send the information that you gave it to identify your users (cookies, typically) along with requests to your site, even ones triggered by a third party (like a malicious script).

If you don't have users, and aren't sending any such information to the browser, your application isn't in danger from CSRF.

user_23957960
Related