What is the difference between these two commands in makefiles:
@echo "Hello World"
$(info Hello World)
As it seems, echo and info print the same output, so where is the difference?
And when to use which one?
Printing in Makefiles: @echo vs $(info )
Viewed 13039
1 Answers
Well, echo is a shell command. So if you put it in a recipe, a shell will be invoked to run it and the shell command will generate the output:
foo: ; @echo "Hello World"
runs /bin/sh -c 'echo "Hello World"'. It can only be used in a recipe. It will work in any version of make, and with any POSIX shell. Because it invokes a shell, you may need to be concerned with quoting issues, etc. (not in this simple example of course).
info is a GNU make function. It is handled directly by make: no shell is invoked. It can appear anywhere in a makefile, not just in a recipe. It is not portable to other versions of make. Because no shell is invoked, there are no quoting issues.
However, because info is a make function it is parsed by make before the shell is invoked: that means it can't show shell variables that are set within a recipe; for example:
foo: ; @for i in a b c d; do $(info $$i); done
cannot work; you must use echo here.
Related