I am using a C library provided to me already compiled. I have limited information on the compiler, version, options, etc., used when compiling the library. The library interface uses enum both in structures that are passed and directly as passed parameters.
The question is: how can I assure or establish that when I compile code to use the provided library, that my compiler will use the same size for those enums? If it does not, the structures won't line up, and the parameter passing may be messed up, e.g. long vs. int.
My concern stems from the C99 standard, which states that the enum type:
shall be compatible with char, a signed integer type, or an unsigned integer type. The choice of type is implementation-defined, but shall be capable of representing the values of all the members of the enumeration.
As far as I can tell, so long as the largest value fits, the compiler can pick any type it darn well pleases, effectively on a whim, potentially varying not only between compilers, but different versions of the same compiler and/or compiler options. It could pick 1, 2, 4, or 8-byte representations, resulting in potential incompatibilities in both structures and parameter passing. (It could also pick signed or unsigned, but I don't see a mechanism for that being a problem in this context.)
Am I missing something here? If I am not missing something, does this mean that enum should never be used in an API?
Update:
Yes, I was missing something. While the language specification doesn't help here, as noted by @Barmar the Application Binary Interface (ABI) does. Or if it doesn't, then the ABI is deficient. The ABI for my system indeed specifies that an enum must be a signed four-byte integer. If a compiler does not obey that, then it is a bug. Given a complete ABI and compliant compilers, enum can be used safely in an API.