Should I return bool or const bool?

user_40834 0
Viewed 31155

Which is better:

bool MyClass::someQuery() const;

const bool MyClass::someQuery() const;

I've been using 'const bool' since I'm sure I remember hearing it's "what the ints do" (for e.g. comparison operators) but I can't find evidence of that anywhere, mostly due to it being difficult to Google and Intellisense not helping out any ;) Can anyone confirm that?

To me returning const values (this isn't just about bools) makes more sense; it'll prevent temporaries being modified, which is almost always going to be a programmer mistake. I just want something to back that up so I can extol returning const values to my colleagues :)

return-value constants c++
11 Answers

This is an ancient post, but I think it's worth mentioning there is a potential corner case here since C++11. While, as stated by others, it will make no difference whether you use const bool or bool as return type in most cases, if you are using C++11 decltype and associates, e.g. result_of, you could declare a variable with the same type as the returning value of some function, and so the const would actually have an effect in this case.

user_17827920
Related