What is the reason behind "non-static method cannot be referenced from a static context"?

Saj_37740 0
Viewed 932601

The very common beginner mistake is when you try to use a class property "statically" without making an instance of that class. It leaves you with the mentioned error message:

You can either make the non static method static or make an instance of that class to use its properties.

What the reason behind this? Am not concern with the solution, rather the reason.

private java.util.List<String> someMethod(){
    /* Some Code */
    return someList;            
}

public static void main(String[] strArgs){          
     // The following statement causes the error. 
    java.util.List<String> someList = someMethod();         
}
static java
13 Answers

You can't call something that doesn't exist. Since you haven't created an object, the non-static method doesn't exist yet. A static method (by definition) always exists.

Brian_Knoblauch_156890

The method you are trying to call is an instance-level method; you do not have an instance.

static methods belong to the class, non-static methods belong to instances of the class.

Steven_A_Lowe_93450

The essence of object oriented programming is encapsulating logic together with the data it operates on.

Instance methods are the logic, instance fields are the data. Together, they form an object.

public class Foo
{
    private String foo;
    public Foo(String foo){ this.foo = foo; }
    public getFoo(){ return this.foo; }

    public static void main(String[] args){
        System.out.println( getFoo() );
    }
}

What could possibly be the result of running the above program?

Without an object, there is no instance data, and while the instance methods exist as part of the class definition, they need an object instance to provide data for them.

In theory, an instance method that does not access any instance data could work in a static context, but then there isn't really any reason for it to be an instance method. It's a language design decision to allow it anyway rather than making up an extra rule to forbid it.

user_168830

I just realized, I think people shouldn't be exposed to the concept of "static" very early.

Static methods should probably be the exception rather than the norm. Especially early on anyways if you want to learn OOP. (Why start with an exception to the rule?) That's very counter-pedagogical of Java, that the "first" thing you should learn is the public static void main thing. (Few real Java applications have their own main methods anyways.)

Hugo_9720

The answers so far describe why, but here is a something else you might want to consider:

You can can call a method from an instantiable class by appending a method call to its constructor, 

Object instance = new Constuctor().methodCall();

or

primitive name = new Constuctor().methodCall();

This is useful it you only wish to use a method of an instantiable class once within a single scope. If you are calling multiple methods from an instantiable class within a single scope, definitely create a referable instance.

set_Sign_NEUTRAL_48570

A static method relates an action to a type of object, whereas the non static method relates an action to an instance of that type of object. Typically it is a method that does something with relation to the instance.

Ex:

class Car might have a wash method, which would indicate washing a particular car, whereas a static method would apply to the type car.

Robin_219250

if a method is not static, that "tells" the compiler that the method requires access to instance-level data in the class, (like a non-static field). This data would not be available unless an instance of the class has been created. So the compiler throws an error if you try to call the method from a static method.. If in fact the method does NOT reference any non-static member of the class, make the method static.

In Resharper, for example, just creating a non-static method that does NOT reference any static member of the class generates a warning message "This method can be made static"

user_326320

The compiler actually adds an argument to non-static methods. It adds a this pointer/reference. This is also the reason why a static method can not use this, because there is no object.

Admin1
Related