https://mysite.ink is not forwarding to https://www.mysite.ink (same for http)
If I go directly to https://www.mysite.ink to see the content that is hosted on heroku. (same for http)
Here are the relevant settings in heroku for the app:

The forwarding settings were already in place for my domain, I haven't changed them. 
Here's the CNAME record. Maybe I am being overcautious pixelating things. I believe all the necessary info is there. Mainly, I believe the concern is where I have "www" and where I have the naked root domain.

I believe that's all my settings
Please let me know if you need anymore info to see the problem.
Thanks!