I am working on .Net core Identity Web App (MVC) and i scaffold identity and get folder under Areas named Identity I do not want to use Razor pages in my MVC app so is there any solution to scaffold identity in Controller/View ? and please mention why Microsoft use this approach any benefit using razor pages in MVC app.
Thanks
There's an explanation in this GitHub issue:
The only current option also seems to be using Razor Pages for the Identity UI. Some of us want full control over how we use Identity so that we can customize it to our needs. The current setup is simply unacceptable. If my entire project is using MVC, I don't want Identity living in its own folder off in la-la land as Razor Pages. It makes the project structure a mess, and there's just no reason for it.
Maintaining two versions of the same codebase (MVC and Razor Pages) is very expensive for us and there are no real benefits from having an MVC implementation compared to a Razor Pages version. Both flavors are fully in ASP.NET. Moving the code out of the area should be relatively straight forward, as well as converting it to MVC from Razor Pages. It probably simply involves moving the pages from the area into your main app Pages folder and calling AddIdentity instead of AddDefaultIdentity.
Please either fix the options so that those who want it can take full control of Identity and use it as they wish, whether that's the MVC approach or the Razor Pages approach. Or provide us with sufficient documentation so that we may add Identity to a blank project without using the Identity UI library or some magic scaffolding voodoo. As it stands now, there doesn't appear to be any documentation on Identity that doesn't rely on the new scaffolding system and Identity UI.
The default UI is completely optional. You should be able to just scaffold the pages into your project and do whatever you want from there, whether that's convert them to an MVC flavor or move them out of the area into your main project.
Summarised: the benefit to this approach is that it is easier to maintain a single version, while there is no downside. The scaffolded UI is optional, you can convert it yourself to an implementation that doesn't use Razor Pages or you can start from scratch.
