Pythonic way to check if a list is sorted or not

Viewed 157380

Is there a pythonic way to check if a list is already sorted in ASC or DESC

listtimestamps = [1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7]

something like isttimestamps.isSorted() that returns True or False.

I want to input a list of timestamps for some messages and check if the the transactions appeared in the correct order.

27 Answers

I ran a benchmark and sorted(lst, reverse=True) == lst was the fastest for long lists, and all(l[i] >= l[i+1] for i in xrange(len(l)-1)) was the fastest for short lists. These benchmarks were run on a MacBook Pro 2010 13" (Core2 Duo 2.66GHz, 4GB 1067MHz DDR3 RAM, Mac OS X 10.6.5).

UPDATE: I revised the script so that you can run it directly on your own system. The previous version had bugs. Also, I have added both sorted and unsorted inputs.

  • Best for short sorted lists: all(l[i] >= l[i+1] for i in xrange(len(l)-1))
  • Best for long sorted lists: sorted(l, reverse=True) == l
  • Best for short unsorted lists: all(l[i] >= l[i+1] for i in xrange(len(l)-1))
  • Best for long unsorted lists: all(l[i] >= l[i+1] for i in xrange(len(l)-1))

So in most cases there is a clear winner.

UPDATE: aaronasterling's answers (#6 and #7) are actually the fastest in all cases. #7 is the fastest because it doesn't have a layer of indirection to lookup the key.

#!/usr/bin/env python

import itertools
import time

def benchmark(f, *args):
    t1 = time.time()
    for i in xrange(1000000):
        f(*args)
    t2 = time.time()
    return t2-t1

L1 = range(4, 0, -1)
L2 = range(100, 0, -1)
L3 = range(0, 4)
L4 = range(0, 100)

# 1.
def isNonIncreasing(l, key=lambda x,y: x >= y): 
    return all(key(l[i],l[i+1]) for i in xrange(len(l)-1))
print benchmark(isNonIncreasing, L1) # 2.47253704071
print benchmark(isNonIncreasing, L2) # 34.5398209095
print benchmark(isNonIncreasing, L3) # 2.1916718483
print benchmark(isNonIncreasing, L4) # 2.19576501846

# 2.
def isNonIncreasing(l):
    return all(l[i] >= l[i+1] for i in xrange(len(l)-1))
print benchmark(isNonIncreasing, L1) # 1.86919999123
print benchmark(isNonIncreasing, L2) # 21.8603689671
print benchmark(isNonIncreasing, L3) # 1.95684289932
print benchmark(isNonIncreasing, L4) # 1.95272517204

# 3.
def isNonIncreasing(l, key=lambda x,y: x >= y): 
    return all(key(a,b) for (a,b) in itertools.izip(l[:-1],l[1:]))
print benchmark(isNonIncreasing, L1) # 2.65468883514
print benchmark(isNonIncreasing, L2) # 29.7504849434
print benchmark(isNonIncreasing, L3) # 2.78062295914
print benchmark(isNonIncreasing, L4) # 3.73436689377

# 4.
def isNonIncreasing(l):
    return all(a >= b for (a,b) in itertools.izip(l[:-1],l[1:]))
print benchmark(isNonIncreasing, L1) # 2.06947803497
print benchmark(isNonIncreasing, L2) # 15.6351969242
print benchmark(isNonIncreasing, L3) # 2.45671010017
print benchmark(isNonIncreasing, L4) # 3.48461818695

# 5.
def isNonIncreasing(l):
    return sorted(l, reverse=True) == l
print benchmark(isNonIncreasing, L1) # 2.01579380035
print benchmark(isNonIncreasing, L2) # 5.44593787193
print benchmark(isNonIncreasing, L3) # 2.01813793182
print benchmark(isNonIncreasing, L4) # 4.97615599632

# 6.
def isNonIncreasing(l, key=lambda x, y: x >= y): 
    for i, el in enumerate(l[1:]):
        if key(el, l[i-1]):
            return False
    return True
print benchmark(isNonIncreasing, L1) # 1.06842684746
print benchmark(isNonIncreasing, L2) # 1.67291283607
print benchmark(isNonIncreasing, L3) # 1.39491200447
print benchmark(isNonIncreasing, L4) # 1.80557894707

# 7.
def isNonIncreasing(l):
    for i, el in enumerate(l[1:]):
        if el >= l[i-1]:
            return False
    return True
print benchmark(isNonIncreasing, L1) # 0.883186101913
print benchmark(isNonIncreasing, L2) # 1.42852401733
print benchmark(isNonIncreasing, L3) # 1.09229516983
print benchmark(isNonIncreasing, L4) # 1.59502696991

As I don't see this option above I will add it to all the answers. Let denote the list by l, then:

import numpy as np

# Trasform the list to a numpy array
x = np.array(l)

# check if ascendent sorted:
all(x[:-1] <= x[1:])

# check if descendent sorted:
all(x[:-1] >= x[1:])

Starting in Python 3.10, the new pairwise function provides a way to slide through pairs of consecutive elements, and thus find if all of these pairs satisfy the same predicate of ordering:

from itertools import pairwise

all(x <= y for x, y in pairwise([1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7]))
# True

The intermediate result of pairwise:

pairwise([1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7])
# [(1, 2), (2, 3), (3, 5), (5, 6), (6, 7)]

The third-party package method more_itertools.is_sorted hasn't been mentioned yet:

import more_itertools

ls = [1, 4, 2]

print(more_itertools.is_sorted(ls))

ls2 = ["ab", "c", "def"]

print(more_itertools.is_sorted(ls2, key=len))

Python 3.6.8

from more_itertools import pairwise

class AssertionHelper:
    @classmethod
    def is_ascending(cls, data: iter) -> bool:
        for a, b in pairwise(data):
            if a > b:
                return False
        return True

    @classmethod
    def is_descending(cls, data: iter) -> bool:
        for a, b in pairwise(data):
            if a < b:
                return False
        return True

    @classmethod
    def is_sorted(cls, data: iter) -> bool:
        return cls.is_ascending(data) or cls.is_descending(data)
>>> AssertionHelper.is_descending((1, 2, 3, 4))
False
>>> AssertionHelper.is_ascending((1, 2, 3, 4))
True
>>> AssertionHelper.is_sorted((1, 2, 3, 4))
True

A solution using assignment expressions (added in Python 3.8):

def is_sorted(seq):
    seq_iter = iter(seq)
    cur = next(seq_iter, None)
    return all((prev := cur) <= (cur := nxt) for nxt in seq_iter)

z = list(range(10))
print(z)
print(is_sorted(z))

import random
random.shuffle(z)
print(z)
print(is_sorted(z))

z = []
print(z)
print(is_sorted(z))

Gives:

[0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9]
True
[1, 7, 5, 9, 4, 0, 8, 3, 2, 6]
False
[]
True

This approach using Pandas is very slow, but it's noted for completeness. I don't advise using unless the input data is already a Pandas Index or Series.

from typing import Sequence

import pandas as pd

def is_sorted(seq: Sequence, reverse: bool = False) -> bool:
    index = pd.Index(seq)
    if reverse:
        return index.is_monotonic_decreasing
    return index.is_monotonic_increasing
from functools import reduce

# myiterable can be of any iterable type (including list)
isSorted = reduce(lambda r, e: (r[0] and (r[1] or r[2] <= e), False, e), myiterable, (True, True, None))[0]

The derived reduction value is a 3-part tuple of (sortedSoFarFlag, firstTimeFlag, lastElementValue). It initially starts with (True, True, None), which is also used as the result for an empty list (regarded as sorted because there are no out-of-order elements). As it processes each element it calculates new values for the tuple (using previous tuple values with the next elementValue):

[0] (sortedSoFarFlag) evaluates true if: prev_0 is true and (prev_1 is true or prev_2 <= elementValue)
[1] (firstTimeFlag): False
[2] (lastElementValue): elementValue

The final result of the reduction is a tuple of:

[0]: True/False depending on whether the entire list was in sorted order
[1]: True/False depending on whether the list was empty
[2]: the last element value

The first value is the one we're interested in, so we use [0] to grab that from the reduce result.

Try this:

def is_sorted(arr) -> bool:
    for i in range(1, len(arr)):
        if arr[i] < arr[i - 1]:
            return False
    return True

How about this one ? Simple and straightforward.

def is_list_sorted(al):

    llength =len(al)


    for i in range (llength):
        if (al[i-1] > al[i]):
            print(al[i])
            print(al[i+1])
            print('Not sorted')
            return -1

    else :
        print('sorted')
        return  true

Simplest way:

def isSorted(arr):
  i = 1
  while i < len(arr):
    if(result[i] < result[i - 1]):
      return False
    i += 1
  return True
Related