How to redirect stderr in Python?

I have a piece of software I wrote for work that captures stderr to a file like so:

import sys
sys.stderr = open('C:\\err.txt', 'w')

so it's definitely possible.

I believe your problem is that you are creating two instances of writer.

Maybe something more like:

import sys

class writer(object):
    log = []

    def write(self, data):
        self.log.append(data)

logger = writer()
sys.stdout = logger
sys.stderr = logger

You can't do anything in Python code that can capture errors during the compilation of that same code. How could it? If the compiler can't finish compiling the code, it won't run the code, so your redirection hasn't even taken effect yet.

That's where your (undesired) subprocess comes in. You can write Python code that redirects the stdout, then invokes the Python interpreter to compile some other piece of code.

I can't think of an easy way. The python process's standard error is living on a lower level than a python file object (C vs. python).

You could wrap the python script in a second python script and use subprocess.Popen. It's also possible you could pull some magic like this in a single script:

import os
import subprocess
import sys

cat = subprocess.Popen("/bin/cat", stdin=subprocess.PIPE, stdout=subprocess.PIPE)
os.close(sys.stderr.fileno())
os.dup2(cat.stdin.fileno(), sys.stderr.fileno())

And then use select.poll() to check cat.stdout regularly to find output.

Yes, that seems to work.

The problem I foresee is that most of the time, something printed to stderr by python indicates it's about to exit. The more usual way to handle this would be via exceptions.

---------Edit

Somehow I missed the os.pipe() function.

import os, sys
r, w = os.pipe()
os.close(sys.stderr.fileno())
os.dup2(w, sys.stderr.fileno())

Then read from r

To route the output and errors from Windows, you can use the following code outside of your Python file:

python a.py 1> a.out 2>&1

Source: https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/help/110930/redirecting-error-messages-from-command-prompt-stderr-stdout

Since python 3.5 you can use contextlib.redirect_stderr

with open('help.txt', 'w') as f:
    with redirect_stdout(f):
        help(pow)

I found this approach to redirecting stderr particularly helpful. Essentially, it is necessary to understand if your output is stdout or stderr. The difference? Stdout is any output posted by a shell command (think an 'ls' list) while sterr is any error output.

It may be that you want to take a shell commands output and redirect it to a log file only if it is normal output. Using ls as an example here, with an all files flag:

# Imports
import sys
import subprocess

# Open file
log = open("output.txt", "w+")

# Declare command
cmd = 'ls -a'
# Run shell command piping to stdout
result = subprocess.run(cmd, stdout=subprocess.PIPE, shell=True)
# Assuming utf-8 encoding
txt = result.stdout.decode('utf-8')
# Write and close file
log.write(txt)
log.close()

If you wanted to make this an error log, you could do the same with stderr. It's exactly the same code as stdout with stderr in its place. This pipes an error messages that get sent to the console to the log. Doing so actually keeps it from flooding your terminal window as well!

Saw this was a post from a while ago, but figured this could save someone some time :)

Python will not execute your code if there is an error. But you can import your script in another script an catch exceptions. Example:

Script.py

print 'something#

FinalScript.py

from importlib.machinery import SourceFileLoader

try:
    SourceFileLoader("main", "<SCRIPT PATH>").load_module()
except Exception as e:
    # Handle the exception here

To add to Ned's answer, it is difficult to capture the errors on the fly during the compilation.

You can write several print statements in your script and you can stdout to a file, it will stop writing to the file when the error occurs. To debug the code you could check the last logged output and check your script after that point.

Something like this:

# Add to the beginning of the script execution(eg: if __name__ == "__main__":).
from datetime import datetime
dt = datetime.now()
script_dir = os.path.dirname(os.path.abspath(__file__))      # gets the path of the script
stdout_file = script_dir+r'\logs\log'+('').join(str(dt.date()).split("-"))+r'.log'
sys.stdout = open(stdout_file, 'w')

This will create a log file and stream the print statements to the file.

Note: Watch out for escape characters in your filepath while concatenating with script_dir in the second line from the last in the code. You might want something similar to raw string. You can check this thread for this.