Case insensitive string compare in LINQ-to-SQL

Viewed 123584

I've read that it's unwise to use ToUpper and ToLower to perform case-insensitive string comparisons, but I see no alternative when it comes to LINQ-to-SQL. The ignoreCase and CompareOptions arguments of String.Compare are ignored by LINQ-to-SQL (if you're using a case-sensitive database, you get a case-sensitive comparison even if you ask for a case-insensitive comparison). Is ToLower or ToUpper the best option here? Is one better than the other? I thought I read somewhere that ToUpper was better, but I don't know if that applies here. (I'm doing a lot of code reviews and everyone is using ToLower.)

Dim s = From row In context.Table Where String.Compare(row.Name, "test", StringComparison.InvariantCultureIgnoreCase) = 0

This translates to an SQL query that simply compares row.Name with "test" and will not return "Test" and "TEST" on a case-sensitive database.

11 Answers

As you say, there are some important differences between ToUpper and ToLower, and only one is dependably accurate when you're trying to do case insensitive equality checks.

Ideally, the best way to do a case-insensitive equality check would be:

String.Equals(row.Name, "test", StringComparison.OrdinalIgnoreCase)

NOTE, HOWEVER that this does not work in this case! Therefore we are stuck with ToUpper or ToLower.

Note the OrdinalIgnoreCase to make it security-safe. But exactly the type of case (in)sensitive check you use depends on what your purposes is. But in general use Equals for equality checks and Compare when you're sorting, and then pick the right StringComparison for the job.

Michael Kaplan (a recognized authority on culture and character handling such as this) has relevant posts on ToUpper vs. ToLower:

He says "String.ToUpper – Use ToUpper rather than ToLower, and specify InvariantCulture in order to pick up OS casing rules"

I used System.Data.Linq.SqlClient.SqlMethods.Like(row.Name, "test") in my query.

This performs a case-insensitive comparison.

According to the EF Core documentation, the decision not to provide an out of the box translation of case insensibility comparison is by design, mostly due to performance concerns since the DB index wouldn't be used:

.NET provides overloads of string.Equals accepting a StringComparison enum, which allows specifying case-sensitivity and culture for the comparison. By design, EF Core refrains from translating these overloads to SQL, and attempting to use them will result in an exception. For one thing, EF Core does know not which case-sensitive or case-insensitive collation should be used. More importantly, applying a collation would in most cases prevent index usage, significantly impacting performance for a very basic and commonly-used .NET construct.

That being said, starting with EF Core 5.0, it's possible to specify a collation per query, which can be used to perform a case insensitive comparison:

Dim s = From row In context.Table 
        Where EF.Functions.Collate(row.Name, "SQL_Latin1_General_CP1_CI_AS") == "test"

and in C#

var s = context.Table
   .Where(row => EF.Functions.Collate(row.Name, "SQL_Latin1_General_CP1_CI_AS") == "test")

With .NET core, System.Data.Linq.SqlClient.SqlMethods is not available, use this instead

EF.Functions.Like(row.Name, "test")

If you pass a string that is case-insensitive into LINQ-to-SQL it will get passed into the SQL unchanged and the comparison will happen in the database. If you want to do case-insensitive string comparisons in the database all you need to to do is create a lambda expression that does the comparison and the LINQ-to-SQL provider will translate that expression into a SQL query with your string intact.

For example this LINQ query:

from user in Users
where user.Email == "foo@bar.com"
select user

gets translated to the following SQL by the LINQ-to-SQL provider:

SELECT [t0].[Email]
FROM [User] AS [t0]
WHERE [t0].[Email] = @p0
-- note that "@p0" is defined as nvarchar(11)
-- and is passed my value of "foo@bar.com"

As you can see, the string parameter will be compared in SQL which means things ought to work just the way you would expect them to.

Sometimes value stored in Database could contain spaces so running this could be fail

String.Equals(row.Name, "test", StringComparison.OrdinalIgnoreCase)

Solution to this problems is to remove space then convert its case then select like this

 return db.UsersTBs.Where(x => x.title.ToString().ToLower().Replace(" ",string.Empty).Equals(customname.ToLower())).FirstOrDefault();

Note in this case

customname is value to match with Database value

UsersTBs is class

title is the Database column

Related