Is there any way to call the parent version of an overridden method? (C# .NET)

Jader_Dias_48465 0
Viewed 57818

In the code below I tried in two ways to access the parent version of methodTwo, but the result was always 2. Is there any way to get the 1 result from a ChildClass instance without modifying these two classes?

class ParentClass
{
    public int methodOne()
    {
        return methodTwo();
    }

    virtual public int methodTwo()
    {
        return 1;
    }
}

class ChildClass : ParentClass
{
    override public int methodTwo()
    {
        return 2;
    }
}

class Program
{
    static void Main(string[] args)
    {
        var a = new ChildClass();
        Console.WriteLine("a.methodOne(): " + a.methodOne());
        Console.WriteLine("a.methodTwo(): " + a.methodTwo());
        Console.WriteLine("((ParentClass)a).methodTwo(): "
         + ((ParentClass)a).methodTwo());
        Console.ReadLine();
    }
}

Update ChrisW posted this:

From outside the class, I don't know any easy way; but, perhaps, I don't know what happens if you try reflection: use the Type.GetMethod method to find the MethodInfo associated with the method in the ParentClass, and then call MethodInfo.Invoke

That answer was deleted. I'm wondering if that hack could work, just for curiosity.

inheritance .net c#
8 Answers

Inside of ChildClass.methodTwo(), you can call base.methodTwo().

Outside of the class, calling ((ParentClass)a).methodTwo() will call ChildClass.methodTwo. That's the whole reason why virtual methods exist.

Craig_Stuntz_77140

At the IL level, you could probably issue a call rather than a callvirt, and get the job done - but if we limit ourselves to C# ;-p (edit darn! the runtime stops you: VerificationException: "Operation could destabilize the runtime."; remove the virtual and it works fine; too clever by half...)

Inside the ChildClass type, you can use base.methodTwo() - however, this is not possible externally. Nor can you go down more than one level - there is no base.base.Foo() support.

However, if you disable polymorphism using method-hiding, you can get the answer you want, but for bad reasons:

class ChildClass : ParentClass
{
    new public int methodTwo() // bad, do not do
    {
        return 2;
    }
}

Now you can get a different answer from the same object depending on whether the variable is defined as a ChildClass or a ParentClass.

Marc_Gravell_233540

To my knowledge, once a method has been overridden then you can't call the parent method.

user_172110

I would think that it is not possible unless you make instance of the ParentClass directly. Thats the very essense of inheritance, polymorphism...

Jangwenyi_133700
Related