Combining multiple git repositories

Viewed 81479

Let's say I've got a setup that look something like

phd/code/
phd/figures/
phd/thesis/

For historical reasons, these all have their own git repositories. But I'd like to combine them into a single one to simplify things a little. For example, right now I might make two sets of changes and have to do something like

cd phd/code
git commit 
cd ../figures
git commit

It'd be (now) nice to just to perform

cd phd
git commit

There seems to be a couple of ways of doing this using submodules or pulling from my sub-repositories, but that's a little more complex than I'm looking for. At the very least, I'd be happy with

cd phd
git init
git add [[everything that's already in my other repositories]]

but that doesn't seem like a one-liner. Is there anything in git that can help me out?

14 Answers

Here's a solution I gave here:

  1. First do a complete backup of your phd directory: I don't want to be held responsible for your losing years of hard work! ;-)

    $ cp -r phd phd-backup
    
  2. Move the content of phd/code to phd/code/code, and fix the history so that it looks like it has always been there (this uses git's filter-branch command):

    $ cd phd/code
    $ git filter-branch --index-filter \
        'git ls-files -s | sed "s#\t#&code/#" |
         GIT_INDEX_FILE=$GIT_INDEX_FILE.new \
         git update-index --index-info &&
         mv $GIT_INDEX_FILE.new $GIT_INDEX_FILE' HEAD
    
  3. Same for the content of phd/figures and phd/thesis (just replace code with figures and thesis).

    Now your directory structure should look like this:

    phd
      |_code
      |    |_.git
      |    |_code
      |         |_(your code...)
      |_figures
      |    |_.git
      |    |_figures
      |         |_(your figures...)
      |_thesis
           |_.git
           |_thesis
                |_(your thesis...)
    
  4. Then create a git repository in the root directory, pull everything into it and remove the old repositories:

    $ cd phd
    $ git init
    
    $ git pull code
    $ rm -rf code/code
    $ rm -rf code/.git
    
    $ git pull figures --allow-unrelated-histories
    $ rm -rf figures/figures
    $ rm -rf figures/.git
    
    $ git pull thesis --allow-unrelated-histories
    $ rm -rf thesis/thesis
    $ rm -rf thesis/.git
    

    Finally, you should now have what you wanted:

    phd
      |_.git
      |_code
      |    |_(your code...)
      |_figures
      |    |_(your figures...)
      |_thesis
           |_(your thesis...)
    

One nice side to this procedure is that it will leave non-versioned files and directories in place.

Hope this helps.


Just one word of warning though: if your code directory already has a code subdirectory or file, things might go very wrong (same for figures and thesis of course). If that's the case, just rename that directory or file before going through this whole procedure:

$ cd phd/code
$ git mv code code-repository-migration
$ git commit -m "preparing the code directory for migration"

And when the procedure is finished, add this final step:

$ cd phd
$ git mv code/code-repository-migration code/code
$ git commit -m "final step for code directory migration"

Of course, if the code subdirectory or file is not versioned, just use mv instead of git mv, and forget about the git commits.

git-stitch-repo will process the output of git-fast-export --all --date-order on the git repositories given on the command-line, and create a stream suitable for git-fast-import that will create a new repository containing all the commits in a new commit tree that respects the history of all the source repositories.

Perhaps, simply (similarly to the previous answer, but using simpler commands) making in each of the separate old repositories a commit that moves the content into a suitably named subdir, e.g.:

$ cd phd/code
$ mkdir code
# This won't work literally, because * would also match the new code/ subdir, but you understand what I mean:
$ git mv * code/
$ git commit -m "preparing the code directory for migration"

and then merging the three separate repos into one new, by doing smth like:

$ cd ../..
$ mkdir phd.all
$ cd phd.all
$ git init
$ git pull ../phd/code
...

Then you'll save your histories, but will go on with a single repo.

You could try the subtree merge strategy. It will let you merge repo B into repo A. The advantage over git-filter-branch is it doesn't require you to rewrite your history of repo A (breaking SHA1 sums).

git-stitch-repo from Aristotle Pagaltzis' answer only works for repositories with simple, linear history.

MiniQuark's answer works for all repositories, but it does not handle tags and branches.

I created a program that works the same way as MiniQuark describes, but it uses one merge commit (with N parents) and also recreates all tags and branches to point to these merge commits.

See the git-merge-repos repository for examples how to use it.

The sequence you suggested

git init
git add *
git commit -a -m "import everything"

will work, but you will lose your commit history.

This bash script works around the sed tab character issue (on MacOS for example) and the issue of missing files.

export SUBREPO="subrepo"; # <= your subrepository name here
export TABULATOR=`printf '\t'`;
FILTER='git ls-files -s | sed "s#${TABULATOR}#&${SUBREPO}/#" |
  GIT_INDEX_FILE=$GIT_INDEX_FILE.new \
  git update-index --index-info &&
  if [ -f "$GIT_INDEX_FILE.new" ]; then mv $GIT_INDEX_FILE.new $GIT_INDEX_FILE; else echo "git filter skipped missing file: $GIT_INXEX_FILE.new"; fi'

git filter-branch --index-filter "$FILTER" HEAD

This is a combination of miniquark, marius-butuc and ryan's posts. Cheers to them!

I combined 3 git repositories into one manually with the help of Git integration in IntelliJ IDEA Community Edition.

  1. Create a new repo, add a new commit to the master branch with an empty README.md file.
  2. Add three remotes for the new repo, using the name of the 3 repositories and the remote URL of them respectively. Run Git Fetch.
  3. Create a new local branch named temp based on the master branch, so we can start over without pollute the master branch. Checkout the temp branch.
  4. Select to only show commits of one remote branch(one repository).
  5. Select all the commits and right click to Cherry-Pick them.
  6. Create directory structure for this repository, then move the files into it and commit.
  7. Repeat the step 4 to 6 for the other 2 remote branch(repository).
  8. When everything is OK, merge all the changes in the temp branch into master branch.

Then add the origin remote URL for master branch and push to it.

Related